CBP Ruling HQ H350722: Where CBP Drew the Line on AI Classification Tools

What changed: Our two other HQ H350722 posts merged in: the penalty for customs business without a license, the earlier six-digit rulings, and an FAQ with three questions to ask about any AI classification tool.

The short answer

CBP ruling HQ H350722, dated January 16, 2026, held that an unlicensed company's AI tool suggesting HTS subheadings beyond six digits, for goods that will be entered, is customs business that needs a broker license. A six-digit tool, or a general reference tool kept apart from entry filing with a meaningfully implemented disclaimer, was permissible. CBP added that "A tool does not constitute a 'person'", so a licensed broker must make the classification decision. For a brokerage running OCR or AI on 300 entries a month, the ruling is about who decides, not which software.

Next step:Try the Classification Researcher on one product

In this post
  1. What did CBP rule about AI classification tools in HQ H350722?
  2. What were the four services CBP reviewed?
  3. Where is the line between classification research and customs business?
  4. Why does CBP say a tool is not a person?
  5. What does HQ H350722 mean for brokers and importers?
  6. Is HQ H350722 the first ruling on AI classification tools?
  7. Where does GingerControl stand?
  8. Keeping up with CBP rulings like this one
  9. References

HQ H350722 is internal advice that CBP's Automotive and Aerospace Center of Excellence and Expertise in Detroit requested on July 23, 2025, about "a foreign entity operating an online platform that provides various services to potential importers for a fee" [1]. I'm Chen Cui, a GingerControl co-founder. We build classification software, so we read this ruling closely; this post quotes it wherever it can, and it is not legal advice. Every quote below comes from the full text of the rulings in CROSS and of the U.S. Code, read on October 11, 2026.

What did CBP rule about AI classification tools in HQ H350722?

CBP ruled that the platform was "impermissibly conducting customs business by ... deriving HTSUS subheading suggestions beyond the six-digit level via its AI classification tool if the merchandise being classified will be entered" [1]. The full holding finds customs business in three services and clears one:

"The Unlicensed Company is not conducting customs business by connecting importers to brokers if the company is merely acting as an intermediary in the transmission of electronic data. The Unlicensed Company is impermissibly conducting customs business by: developing an OCR tool that identifies what data will appear on an entry; deriving HTSUS subheading suggestions beyond the six-digit level via its AI classification tool if the merchandise being classified will be entered; and, submitting and certifying CBP Form 5106 on behalf of others."

The ruling does not say AI classification tools are legal, and it does not say they are banned. It says what made this tool, in this setup, customs business. The stakes are counted per transaction: a person who intentionally transacts customs business for others without a license faces a penalty of up to $10,000 for each transaction under 19 U.S.C. 1641(b)(6) [4].

Review legal limits of trade compliance disclaimers before assuming a general-reference statement changes the customs-business analysis.

What were the four services CBP reviewed?

CBP reviewed four services on one platform and found three of them to be customs business.

ServiceHow CBP describes itCBP's answer
Connecting importers to brokersThe platform passed data between importers and brokersNot customs business when "merely facilitating the electronic transmission of information to a broker but has no role in deciding what is transmitted"; the power-of-attorney flow raised 19 CFR 111.36(c)(3)
OCR extractionA tool to "cull entry data from shipping documents"Customs business: "an unlicensed entity cannot decide what data should appear on an entry"
AI classificationAn importer enters "product name; material; and end-use", and the tool "generates 'tiered' classification suggestions"Customs business beyond six digits for goods that will be entered
CBP Form 5106Certifying and submitting importer identity forms for new importersCustoms business: "only a licensed customs broker may complete and submit CBP Form 5106 on behalf of another party"

Source: [1]. CBP also flagged that a fee tied to entries may raise 19 CFR 111.36(b), and that 19 CFR 111.3(a) requires customs business to be conducted "within the customs territory of the United States".

Where is the line between classification research and customs business?

The line is the nexus to an entry. CBP wrote: "if the Unlicensed Company's AI classification tool only derives potential HTSUS subheadings to the six-digit level, then customs business is not being conducted. However, if the AI classification tool is deriving subheadings beyond the six-digit level, then a customs broker's license is generally required if that classification information will or may eventually be used for an entry" [1]. The six-digit line is not new: CBP drew it in earlier rulings on Importer Security Filing, HQ H045695 (2010) and HQ H260075 (2017), because six digits are not enough to make entry [6].

Two earlier rulings frame the permissible and the impermissible sides:

  • Permissible, like HQ H272798 (2017). A tool giving "general classification information that is disconnected from an actual or intended importation" is "akin to the narrowly permissible database in HQ H272798", "so long as the Unlicensed Company's disclaimer is meaningfully implemented" and the tool "operates separately from the portal connecting importers to brokers for entry purposes" [1] [2]. In H272798, a classification database survived because its disclaimer said the code for a specific entry "is to be determined by the licensed Customhouse broker or other agent engaged to file the entry"; CBP called it "a fine line" [2].
  • Impermissible, like HQ H290535 (2022). Codes beyond six digits given "to customers who have engaged a third-party broker to make entry through the Unlicensed Company's online platform" are "impermissibly directing customers and brokers on how to prepare the requisite entry documents akin to HQ H290535" [1]. In H290535, a product supplier's 8- and 10-digit codes for its retail customers were customs business even with an "advisory only" disclaimer [3].

Review online customs platform compliance requirements before assigning customs business and client-record access across platform participants.

Quotable insight: HQ H350722 does not draw its line around artificial intelligence. It draws it around the entry: the same AI suggestion is general reference when it is cut off from any import and kept away from the broker portal, and customs business when an unlicensed company hands it, beyond six digits, to someone whose goods will be entered. The question for any tool is where its output lands and who decides, not how it was produced.

Why does CBP say a tool is not a person?

Because only a licensed person can make the decision that customs business requires. CBP wrote: "A tool does not constitute a 'person' as defined by 19 C.F.R. § 111.1, such that the actual decision regarding the classification of imported merchandise, or any other information needed to make entry, must be made by a duly licensed customs broker" [1]. And when tools are used for customs business, "an individual broker or other licensed person must have a role in specifying what information, like value or classification, is automatically generated by the tool's decision matrix and ultimately appears on an entry filed with CBP" [1].

For brokers, that is the sentence to read closely. It does not ban a broker from using AI or OCR; it says the licensed person must have a role in what the tool generates and what reaches the entry. How that applies to a given brokerage's review step is a question for its customs counsel.

Check OCR customs data extraction and broker licensing before designing a tool that selects entry-relevant fields from shipping documents.

What does HQ H350722 mean for brokers and importers?

For brokers, the ruling ties together a run of earlier decisions about who may decide entry data; for importers, it changes little about their own goods. Classification for your own imports is not customs business for others: 19 U.S.C. 1641(b)(1) bars conducting customs business "(other than solely on behalf of that person)" without a license [4]. The importer still files the classification "using reasonable care" under 19 U.S.C. 1484, and CBP said in H290535 that "mere reliance by Hampton's customers on Hampton's classification advice does not establish reasonable care" [3].

RulingYearWhat it adds
HQ 1146541999Unlicensed persons may teach the HTS and the GRI, but "may not, however, advise a client on how to classify ... merchandise that is going to be the subject of an entry"
HQ H0682782009A service bureau's software that prepares entries from importer data conducts customs business
HQ H2727982017A classification database with a meaningfully implemented disclaimer does not cross the line
HQ H2905352022"Classifying goods for others is 'customs business'"; six digits is not
HQ H3269262023An offshore company keying entry data into a broker's ABI system conducts customs business
HQ H3507222026The same lines applied to an AI classification tool and an OCR tool

Sources: [1] [2] [3] [5]. The decision tree built from these rulings is in can AI tools legally classify HTS codes?, and the day-to-day procedure in how to use AI classification tools without violating customs law. If you are deciding whether your broker or your own team should own classification, see customs broker vs in-house classification.

Is HQ H350722 the first ruling on AI classification tools?

It is the first CBP ruling we could find in CROSS that addresses an AI classification tool; CBP itself does not call it the first. A full-text CROSS search on October 11, 2026 for "artificial intelligence" returned 38 rulings and "AI classification" one; the others are rulings on products such as robots, chips and smart glasses [1]. Rulings bind CBP on the facts presented, so a different tool in a different setup is a different question.

Where does GingerControl stand?

GingerControl builds software; it is not a customs broker, is not the importer of record, does not file entries and does not give legal advice. Our classifications are for general reference, educational, and planning purposes; before a code goes on an entry, the customer's licensed customs broker reviews it. What our Classification Researcher does, and how it compares with other tools, is in the best automated HTS classification tools and ten HTS classification tools ranked by buyer fit. For a plain explanation of the free government sources these tools draw on, see the best free HTS code lookup tools.

Keeping up with CBP rulings like this one

CBP's rulings on customs business change what tools and brokers may do, and they rarely make headlines. GingerControl's free Policy Briefings send one email when CBP, USTR or the White House changes a U.S. trade rule, with a link to the primary document. Get one email when a trade rule changes

References

  1. U.S. Customs and Border Protection, ruling HQ H350722 (January 16, 2026), "Online platform; conducting customs business without a license" (read in CROSS October 11, 2026)
    Data cited: request of July 23, 2025 from the Automotive and Aerospace Center of Excellence and Expertise; the four services; the six-digit line and nexus to entry; "akin to the narrowly permissible database in HQ H272798"; "akin to HQ H290535"; "A tool does not constitute a 'person'"; OCR and Form 5106 findings; the holding; 19 CFR 111.36(b) and 111.3(a); CROSS full-text search counts on October 11, 2026
    Source: CBP CROSS, HQ H350722; search counts from CBP CROSS full-text search
  2. U.S. Customs and Border Protection, ruling HQ H272798 (January 26, 2017)
    Data cited: the disclaimer for "general, educational and planning purposes only"; "navigate a fine line"; the database does not cross the line if the disclaimer is meaningfully implemented
    Source: CBP CROSS, HQ H272798
  3. U.S. Customs and Border Protection, ruling HQ H290535 (September 29, 2022)
    Data cited: "Classifying goods for others is 'customs business'"; six-digit classification is not customs business; 8- and 10-digit codes with an "advisory only" disclaimer violated 19 U.S.C. 1641(b)(1); "mere reliance ... does not establish reasonable care"
    Source: CBP CROSS, HQ H290535
  4. 19 U.S.C. 1641(b)(1) and (b)(6), and 19 U.S.C. 1484
    Data cited: no person may conduct customs business "(other than solely on behalf of that person)" without a license; a person who intentionally transacts customs business without a license is liable for a penalty of up to $10,000 for each transaction; the importer of record files classification "using reasonable care"
    Source: 19 U.S.C. 1641, U.S. Code, and 19 U.S.C. 1484, U.S. Code
  5. U.S. Customs and Border Protection, rulings HQ 114654 (May 28, 1999), HQ H068278 (September 28, 2009) and HQ H326926 (December 19, 2023)
    Data cited: general advice vs specific classification advice; service bureau software preparing entries; offshore data keying into ABI is customs business
    Source: CBP CROSS, HQ 114654, HQ H068278 and HQ H326926
  6. U.S. Customs and Border Protection, rulings HQ H045695 (October 15, 2010) and HQ H260075 (April 3, 2017)
    Data cited: providing six-digit HTS numbers for Importer Security Filing is not customs business, because six digits are not enough to make entry
    Source: CBP CROSS, HQ H045695 and HQ H260075

Questions people ask

What is CBP ruling HQ H350722?

It is a January 16, 2026 internal advice ruling from CBP Headquarters about an unlicensed foreign company's online platform for importers. CBP held that the platform's AI tool did customs business when it suggested HTS subheadings beyond six digits for goods that will be entered. For a broker or tool buyer, it is the ruling we found in CROSS that addresses an AI classification tool directly.

Does HQ H350722 ban AI classification tools?

No. It held that an unlicensed company's AI tool did customs business when it gave subheadings beyond six digits for goods that will be entered. A tool limited to six digits, or one giving general reference information kept apart from entry filing with a meaningfully implemented disclaimer, was permissible. For a team evaluating three AI tools, the question is who makes the classification decision and how the output reaches an entry.

Can a disclaimer make an AI classification tool legal?

Only if it is meaningfully implemented and the tool stays apart from entry filing. In HQ H350722, CBP accepted the tool as akin to the database in HQ H272798 only so long as it operates separately from the portal connecting importers to brokers. In HQ H290535, a supplier's disclaimer did not save 8- and 10-digit codes given for goods about to be entered.

What should brokers using AI or OCR extraction tools do after the H350722 ruling?

Read the ruling's point on who decides: CBP said a licensed person must have a role in specifying what the tool generates and what appears on the entry, and that an unlicensed entity cannot decide what data goes on an entry, whether extracted by hand or by OCR. For a brokerage filing 300 entries a month, ask your customs counsel how your review step fits that language.

Is a six-digit HS code suggestion customs business?

No. CBP has consistently held that classifying goods to the six-digit level is not customs business and needs no broker license, and HQ H350722 repeats that a tool deriving only six-digit subheadings does not conduct customs business. For an e-commerce platform serving 2,000 sellers, the line moves once the tool gives 8 or 10 digits for goods that will be entered.

Can an importer use AI to classify its own goods?

Yes. The license requirement covers customs business conducted for others; 19 U.S.C. 1641(b)(1) excepts business done solely on a person's own behalf. The importer still files the classification using reasonable care under 19 U.S.C. 1484, and HQ H290535 says mere reliance on a supplier's classification advice does not establish reasonable care. For an importer with 800 SKUs, keep the reasoning for each code.

Who can submit CBP Form 5106 for a new importer?

Only the party itself or a licensed customs broker. HQ H350722, the first ruling to address the point, said only a licensed customs broker may complete and submit CBP Form 5106 on behalf of another party, and found the platform's certifying and submitting of Form 5106 for others was customs business. For a platform onboarding 50 new importers a month, that step belongs with a broker.

Can an offshore team prepare entry data for a U.S. customs broker?

Not if the work is customs business. In HQ H326926 (December 19, 2023), CBP found that an unlicensed offshore company keying entry data into a broker's ABI system would conduct customs business, even with the broker auditing the data. Since December 19, 2022, 19 CFR 111.3(a) also requires customs business to be conducted within the U.S. customs territory.

What is the penalty for conducting customs business without a license?

Up to $10,000 per transaction. Under 19 U.S.C. 1641(b)(6), a person who intentionally transacts customs business for others without a license is liable for a monetary penalty of up to $10,000 for each such transaction and for each violation of the section's other provisions. For an unlicensed platform touching 300 entries a month, the exposure is counted transaction by transaction.

What should we ask about an AI classification tool after HQ H350722?

Three questions. Does it give subheadings beyond six digits for goods that will be entered? Does it run separately from any portal that connects importers to brokers for entry? Is its disclaimer meaningfully implemented, with a licensed broker deciding what goes on the entry? For a team comparing three tools, a yes to the first makes the other two the ones to take to customs counsel.

Your next step

Classifying SKUs one ruling at a time?

Hand this to GingerOS.

Get your SKU list classified, reasons included Try the Classification Researcher on one product

Pick a 30-minute slot on the next page with Chen Cui, our CEO. Bring one notice or one SKU list (an ERP export, a spreadsheet or an email will do) and see what GingerOS does with it.

Reviewed by Michael Weick, LCB / CCS
Customs compliance manager with 42 years of experience (ex Subaru of America, Merck, and Motorola).

More in AI & Technology

Our Risk-Free Promise

Full refund.

If you’re not satisfied before MVP acceptance, get a full refund of your deposit.

Click Me!

See if you qualify